The growing wave of medical practice acquisitions by private companies like CVS and Amazon is currently disrupting the healthcare sector. Here’s what today’s physicians should know about the current trend and what to consider if their own practice is ever approached for acquisition.
According to Forbes, private equity’s interest in the healthcare sector began in 2013. By 2016, firms acquired more than 350 physician practices and, over the next four years, nearly 600 more. According to a recent report from Physicians Advocacy Institute, nearly seven out of 10 doctors are currently employed by a hospital or larger corporate entity.
Household name brands like Amazon and CVS have made recent headlines by aggressively pursuing this market. Last year, Amazon bought One Medical for roughly $4 billion. More recently, CVS Health (which also owns insurer Aetna) acquired Oak Street Health for $11 billion. Oak Street Health has locations in more than 20 different states.
Walgreens, Walmart, and Cigna are just a few of the other marquee companies who have made headlines by investing in or outright acquiring practices and doctor groups. If your practice has been approached about acquisition, make sure you know your financial options. Need help? Call our team of advisors today.
According to Reed Abelson’s recent article in the New York Times, corporations have two major business interests in the healthcare industry. One major prospect is to assert more control over where patients and their insurers spend money.
Primary physicians see the most number of patients in any given market and, once these physicians become employees of a corporation, they can easily divert patients to preferred providers for prescriptions, lab work, hospital visits, etc.
In many cases, the corporations who own these doctor groups also run the other facilities providing secondary care. For instance, One Medical might instruct patients to receive prescriptions from Amazon's online pharmacy.
Secondly, there’s Medicare Advantage — a Medicare-approved plan (commonly called “Part C” or an “MA Plan”) that is offered by private insurers. The federal government pays $400 billion in reimbursements annually to insurers who provide these plans.
Because the government subsidizes these plans, they tend to be highly profitable for insurers and healthcare providers. In 2022, about half of One Medical’s revenue came from Medicare Advantage patients. These patients only represented five percent of One Medical’s customers.
The private companies behind all this consolidation argue that, ultimately, acquiring practices and doctor groups is beneficial for all parties. “The salaries of the folks [doctors] in those arrangements are higher," the CEO of the Primary Care Collaborative, Ann Greiner, told the New York Times. "They are providing more comprehensive care in many of those arrangements. They are providing more tech and more team-based care. That's all investment."
While legislators intended Medicare Advantage to help provide easier access to Medicare benefits, industry experts have criticized the program for allowing insurers (and/or their parent companies) to profit from overstating how sick patients were. The Biden Administration is proposing new rules that would limit some of the most common and problematic claims under Medicare Advantage plans.
Some doctors have also voiced concerns that corporate consolidation has turned them into mere employees and negatively impacted patient relationships. Dr. Dan Moore of Virginia told the New York Times that corporate stewardship often means a loss of autonomy for doctors, adding: “You don't become a physician to spend an average of seven minutes with a patient.”
Other physicians are worried that, despite corporate touting of patient-focused, “value-based care,” there is a debilitating focus on profits. Dr. Beth Kozak of Grand Rapids, Michigan, told the New York Times that after Agilon Health partnered with her doctor group, she has had to work longer hours to make more diagnoses that result in Medicare reimbursements.
"It's not because I'm giving better patient care," she told the Times. "It's all tied to the billing."
Forbes recently summarized what a typical private equity acquisition for a physician’s practice looks like. Here’s what a doctor can expect:
Earlier this year, Medical Economics also reported that — after a record-breaking spike in 2021 — investor appetite in the healthcare sector remains significant. Last year, it was common to see practice valuations at 11–14 times EBITDA (earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization). Currently, 5–8 times EBITDA is more common.
Physicians who are looking to sell their practice and stay on as a part-owner or employee should consider a number of different factors when negotiating with a private equity firm. Just a few of these are:
It’s also critical that physicians be aware of state laws that could affect the acquisition of their practice. A growing number of state governments have become wary of private equity acquisitions in the healthcare space and have put new regulations in place — or plan to in the near future.
Selling a practice isn’t right for everyone but, in many cases, can be beneficial for all parties, including patients. If you’re currently fielding an offer on your practice from a private equity firm, Forme Financial can help.
Our experienced financial advisors specialize in physician wealth management and can provide tailored financial guidance during the course of an acquisition. Forme Financial can help ensure a secure financial future for this next stage of your career and beyond.
To learn more, contact our team today.
The information provided herein was prepared for educational purposes only and is not a solicitation to buy or sell any security or insurance product, nor an offer to provide investment advice. All examples are hypothetical and for illustrative purposes only. Nothing contained herein should be construed as legal or tax advice and is not intended to replace the advice of a qualified tax advisor or legal professional. The information contained herein may have been compiled from third-party sources we believe to be reliable but cannot guarantee its accuracy or completeness.
Forme Financial is an SEC-registered investment adviser. Additional information about Forme Financial, including its services and fees, is available online at http://adviserinfo.sec.gov/.
This communication contains past specific securities recommendations for illustrative purpose only. Forme Financial makes no assurances, nor should it be assumed, that recommendations made in the future will be profitable or will equal the performance of the securities included in this presentation. Due to various factors including changing market conditions, such recommendations may no longer be appropriate; nor should any past recommendation be taken as personalized investment advice. You may request from us free of charge a list of all securities recommendation made within the immediately preceding period of at least one year accompanied by the following disclosures: (1) the name of each security recommended; (2) the date and nature of each recommendation; (3) the market price of the security recommended at the time; (4) the price at which the recommendation was to be acted upon; (5) the market price of each such security as of the most recent practicable date. It should not be assumed that recommendations made in the future will be profitable or will equal the performance of the securities in this list. Any presentation of the performance of such past specific securities recommendation does not reflect the deduction of an investment management fee, or any transaction costs or custodial charges, the incurrence of which would have the effect of decreasing indicated historical performance results. It should not be assumed that your account performance of the volatility of securities held in your account will of will correspond directly to the referenced past securities recommendations.
Learn more about Forme Financial and how we can impact your financial future.
Forme was purpose-built to assist physicians with their wealth management needs regardless of career stage. We have a highly experienced team of experts - combined with the right technology to offer the most comprehensive coordinated and integrated financial services available.
Thank you for your interest, we'll be in contact with you soon.
Looking for financial tips and insights curated specifically for physicians? You'll find it in our newsletter, written by our Forme Financial wealth management experts